Among 319 of GitHub’s most popular repos run by an organization, the median one had only 26% of its merged pull requests reviewed with comments by someone other than their author. 35% were approved without a word, and 22% were merged with no review from another person at all.
First the teams: every repo run by an organization, one column each.
How the merged PRs of each repo run by an organization were reviewed Each column is one of 319 repos, sorted by the share of its PRs reviewed with comments. How the merged PRs of each repo run by an organization were reviewed Each column is one of 319 repos, sorted by the share of its PRs reviewed with comments. Reviewed with comments Approved, no comment No other human review 0% 50% 100% godotengine/godot: 98.4% reviewed with comments, 1.2% approved with no comment, 0.4% no other review elastic/elasticsearch: 94.0% reviewed with comments, 0.9% approved with no comment, 5.1% no other review angular/angular: 91.0% reviewed with comments, 4.4% approved with no comment, 4.6% no other review bitcoin/bitcoin: 88.7% reviewed with comments, 5.3% approved with no comment, 6.0% no other review OpenRA/OpenRA: 87.3% reviewed with comments, 9.7% approved with no comment, 3.0% no other review etcd-io/etcd: 77.0% reviewed with comments, 22.6% approved with no comment, 0.4% no other review nexu-io/open-design: 77.0% reviewed with comments, 22.4% approved with no comment, 0.6% no other review reactos/reactos: 74.1% reviewed with comments, 22.0% approved with no comment, 3.9% no other review qbittorrent/qBittorrent: 73.3% reviewed with comments, 26.7% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review redis/redis: 72.8% reviewed with comments, 26.8% approved with no comment, 0.4% no other review apache/kafka: 72.7% reviewed with comments, 27.2% approved with no comment, 0.1% no other review kubernetes/kubernetes: 70.6% reviewed with comments, 3.6% approved with no comment, 25.8% no other review apache/flink: 67.3% reviewed with comments, 30.0% approved with no comment, 2.7% no other review pingcap/tidb: 66.2% reviewed with comments, 33.3% approved with no comment, 0.5% no other review valkey-io/valkey: 65.8% reviewed with comments, 34.0% approved with no comment, 0.2% no other review dotnet/runtime: 65.5% reviewed with comments, 34.5% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review pytorch/pytorch: 65.2% reviewed with comments, 31.2% approved with no comment, 3.6% no other review django/django: 64.6% reviewed with comments, 33.6% approved with no comment, 1.8% no other review vllm-project/vllm: 64.1% reviewed with comments, 32.7% approved with no comment, 3.2% no other review nginx/nginx: 62.6% reviewed with comments, 35.1% approved with no comment, 2.3% no other review systemd/systemd: 62.5% reviewed with comments, 25.7% approved with no comment, 11.8% no other review scikit-learn/scikit-learn: 62.5% reviewed with comments, 37.5% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review bytedance/deer-flow: 62.3% reviewed with comments, 36.0% approved with no comment, 1.7% no other review python/cpython: 60.9% reviewed with comments, 20.4% approved with no comment, 18.7% no other review go-gitea/gitea: 60.8% reviewed with comments, 39.2% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review opencv/opencv: 60.4% reviewed with comments, 29.2% approved with no comment, 10.4% no other review huggingface/transformers: 60.4% reviewed with comments, 29.9% approved with no comment, 9.7% no other review tailscale/tailscale: 60.2% reviewed with comments, 39.8% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review ggml-org/llama.cpp: 58.4% reviewed with comments, 34.2% approved with no comment, 7.4% no other review micropython/micropython: 57.6% reviewed with comments, 28.5% approved with no comment, 13.9% no other review redisson/redisson: 57.6% reviewed with comments, 1.5% approved with no comment, 40.9% no other review career-ops-hq/career-ops: 57.5% reviewed with comments, 1.4% approved with no comment, 41.1% no other review keycloak/keycloak: 57.0% reviewed with comments, 42.0% approved with no comment, 1.0% no other review mozilla/pdf.js: 57.0% reviewed with comments, 30.7% approved with no comment, 12.3% no other review juspay/hyperswitch: 56.2% reviewed with comments, 43.7% approved with no comment, 0.1% no other review microsoft/terminal: 56.0% reviewed with comments, 44.0% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review FreeCAD/FreeCAD: 55.3% reviewed with comments, 9.0% approved with no comment, 35.7% no other review caddyserver/caddy: 55.2% reviewed with comments, 42.9% approved with no comment, 1.9% no other review traefik/traefik: 54.8% reviewed with comments, 45.2% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review zephyrproject-rtos/zephyr: 54.5% reviewed with comments, 45.5% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review obsproject/obs-studio: 53.7% reviewed with comments, 37.4% approved with no comment, 8.9% no other review milvus-io/milvus: 53.7% reviewed with comments, 14.9% approved with no comment, 31.4% no other review keepassxreboot/keepassxc: 53.5% reviewed with comments, 46.5% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review bevyengine/bevy: 52.7% reviewed with comments, 46.7% approved with no comment, 0.6% no other review deskflow/deskflow: 52.6% reviewed with comments, 45.0% approved with no comment, 2.4% no other review firecracker-microvm/firecracker: 52.2% reviewed with comments, 47.8% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review aquasecurity/trivy: 50.7% reviewed with comments, 49.3% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review php/php-src: 50.6% reviewed with comments, 35.2% approved with no comment, 14.2% no other review carbon-language/carbon-lang: 50.6% reviewed with comments, 49.4% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review floci-io/floci: 50.2% reviewed with comments, 40.5% approved with no comment, 9.3% no other review AvaloniaUI/Avalonia: 49.9% reviewed with comments, 49.6% approved with no comment, 0.5% no other review dotnet/roslyn: 49.9% reviewed with comments, 39.7% approved with no comment, 10.4% no other review ppy/osu: 49.8% reviewed with comments, 48.4% approved with no comment, 1.8% no other review hoppscotch/hoppscotch: 49.5% reviewed with comments, 49.1% approved with no comment, 1.4% no other review TeamNewPipe/NewPipe: 49.4% reviewed with comments, 43.8% approved with no comment, 6.8% no other review dragonflydb/dragonfly: 48.7% reviewed with comments, 51.3% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review istio/istio: 48.4% reviewed with comments, 22.4% approved with no comment, 29.2% no other review google/gson: 48.4% reviewed with comments, 48.4% approved with no comment, 3.2% no other review serverless/serverless: 47.8% reviewed with comments, 0.8% approved with no comment, 51.4% no other review dotnet/maui: 47.3% reviewed with comments, 39.7% approved with no comment, 13.0% no other review envoyproxy/envoy: 46.9% reviewed with comments, 51.0% approved with no comment, 2.1% no other review bazelbuild/bazel: 46.6% reviewed with comments, 51.7% approved with no comment, 1.7% no other review Genymobile/scrcpy: 46.2% reviewed with comments, 0.0% approved with no comment, 53.8% no other review ansible/ansible: 45.8% reviewed with comments, 38.0% approved with no comment, 16.2% no other review microsoft/PowerToys: 45.5% reviewed with comments, 54.5% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review nodejs/node: 45.1% reviewed with comments, 54.9% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review dbeaver/dbeaver: 44.6% reviewed with comments, 22.2% approved with no comment, 33.2% no other review strapi/strapi: 44.4% reviewed with comments, 54.6% approved with no comment, 1.0% no other review grpc/grpc: 44.3% reviewed with comments, 55.1% approved with no comment, 0.6% no other review microsoft/TypeScript: 44.3% reviewed with comments, 55.7% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review yt-dlp/yt-dlp: 44.3% reviewed with comments, 32.2% approved with no comment, 23.5% no other review meteor/meteor: 44.2% reviewed with comments, 30.8% approved with no comment, 25.0% no other review google-gemini/gemini-cli: 43.9% reviewed with comments, 55.0% approved with no comment, 1.1% no other review qmk/qmk_firmware: 43.0% reviewed with comments, 43.5% approved with no comment, 13.5% no other review astral-sh/ruff: 43.0% reviewed with comments, 27.9% approved with no comment, 29.1% no other review FuelLabs/sway: 42.9% reviewed with comments, 57.1% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review alibaba/open-code-review: 42.4% reviewed with comments, 52.9% approved with no comment, 4.7% no other review warpdotdev/warp: 42.2% reviewed with comments, 57.5% approved with no comment, 0.3% no other review netty/netty: 42.1% reviewed with comments, 21.0% approved with no comment, 36.9% no other review dotnet/efcore: 42.0% reviewed with comments, 57.8% approved with no comment, 0.2% no other review keras-team/keras: 41.9% reviewed with comments, 55.7% approved with no comment, 2.4% no other review tauri-apps/tauri: 41.9% reviewed with comments, 51.1% approved with no comment, 7.0% no other review microsoft/WSL: 41.6% reviewed with comments, 58.4% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review hyprwm/Hyprland: 41.2% reviewed with comments, 34.7% approved with no comment, 24.1% no other review vercel/next.js: 40.9% reviewed with comments, 58.1% approved with no comment, 1.0% no other review servo/servo: 40.9% reviewed with comments, 41.2% approved with no comment, 17.9% no other review rtk-ai/rtk: 40.7% reviewed with comments, 24.2% approved with no comment, 35.1% no other review ClickHouse/ClickHouse: 40.6% reviewed with comments, 32.2% approved with no comment, 27.2% no other review MonoGame/MonoGame: 40.3% reviewed with comments, 56.1% approved with no comment, 3.6% no other review ethereum/go-ethereum: 40.2% reviewed with comments, 56.3% approved with no comment, 3.5% no other review fastify/fastify: 39.9% reviewed with comments, 54.6% approved with no comment, 5.5% no other review prometheus/prometheus: 39.8% reviewed with comments, 59.7% approved with no comment, 0.5% no other review mpv-player/mpv: 39.3% reviewed with comments, 18.0% approved with no comment, 42.7% no other review n8n-io/n8n: 39.2% reviewed with comments, 59.3% approved with no comment, 1.5% no other review PowerShell/PowerShell: 38.5% reviewed with comments, 61.5% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review lvgl/lvgl: 38.2% reviewed with comments, 60.2% approved with no comment, 1.6% no other review 1Panel-dev/1Panel: 37.5% reviewed with comments, 0.0% approved with no comment, 62.5% no other review dotnet/BenchmarkDotNet: 37.4% reviewed with comments, 38.4% approved with no comment, 24.2% no other review hashicorp/terraform: 37.3% reviewed with comments, 62.7% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review tesseract-ocr/tesseract: 37.2% reviewed with comments, 34.9% approved with no comment, 27.9% no other review grafana/grafana: 37.2% reviewed with comments, 61.3% approved with no comment, 1.5% no other review electron/electron: 36.8% reviewed with comments, 63.1% approved with no comment, 0.1% no other review rclone/rclone: 36.7% reviewed with comments, 61.3% approved with no comment, 2.0% no other review jqlang/jq: 36.6% reviewed with comments, 54.9% approved with no comment, 8.5% no other review Significant-Gravitas/AutoGPT: 36.6% reviewed with comments, 31.9% approved with no comment, 31.5% no other review libuv/libuv: 36.3% reviewed with comments, 54.8% approved with no comment, 8.9% no other review mem0ai/mem0: 36.3% reviewed with comments, 62.4% approved with no comment, 1.3% no other review mermaid-js/mermaid: 36.1% reviewed with comments, 30.5% approved with no comment, 33.4% no other review dotnet/aspnetcore: 36.0% reviewed with comments, 43.2% approved with no comment, 20.8% no other review moby/moby: 36.0% reviewed with comments, 63.9% approved with no comment, 0.1% no other review docling-project/docling: 35.8% reviewed with comments, 64.2% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review jellyfin/jellyfin: 35.6% reviewed with comments, 64.4% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review apache/superset: 35.6% reviewed with comments, 59.7% approved with no comment, 4.7% no other review typst/typst: 35.4% reviewed with comments, 1.1% approved with no comment, 63.5% no other review files-community/Files: 35.2% reviewed with comments, 29.4% approved with no comment, 35.4% no other review bitwarden/server: 34.9% reviewed with comments, 65.1% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review ml-explore/mlx: 34.9% reviewed with comments, 65.1% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review SerenityOS/serenity: 34.9% reviewed with comments, 11.3% approved with no comment, 53.8% no other review freeCodeCamp/freeCodeCamp: 34.9% reviewed with comments, 61.3% approved with no comment, 3.8% no other review docker/compose: 34.6% reviewed with comments, 65.4% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review spectreconsole/spectre.console: 34.3% reviewed with comments, 54.3% approved with no comment, 11.4% no other review cli/cli: 34.3% reviewed with comments, 60.4% approved with no comment, 5.3% no other review apache/incubator-seata: 34.0% reviewed with comments, 66.0% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review docsifyjs/docsify: 34.0% reviewed with comments, 56.4% approved with no comment, 9.6% no other review rust-lang/rust: 33.4% reviewed with comments, 1.0% approved with no comment, 65.6% no other review meilisearch/meilisearch: 33.2% reviewed with comments, 66.8% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review withastro/astro: 33.2% reviewed with comments, 65.7% approved with no comment, 1.1% no other review usebruno/bruno: 33.0% reviewed with comments, 56.4% approved with no comment, 10.6% no other review immich-app/immich: 33.0% reviewed with comments, 66.9% approved with no comment, 0.1% no other review mui/material-ui: 32.9% reviewed with comments, 62.8% approved with no comment, 4.3% no other review aaif-goose/goose: 32.7% reviewed with comments, 62.7% approved with no comment, 4.6% no other review JustArchiNET/ArchiSteamFarm: 32.4% reviewed with comments, 0.0% approved with no comment, 67.6% no other review langflow-ai/langflow: 32.3% reviewed with comments, 54.8% approved with no comment, 12.9% no other review gchq/CyberChef: 31.9% reviewed with comments, 65.8% approved with no comment, 2.3% no other review react/react: 31.9% reviewed with comments, 58.5% approved with no comment, 9.6% no other review timescale/timescaledb: 31.8% reviewed with comments, 68.2% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review github/spec-kit: 31.7% reviewed with comments, 14.7% approved with no comment, 53.6% no other review microsoft/semantic-kernel: 31.4% reviewed with comments, 65.4% approved with no comment, 3.2% no other review microsoft/playwright: 30.8% reviewed with comments, 69.2% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review espressif/esp-idf: 30.6% reviewed with comments, 0.0% approved with no comment, 69.4% no other review ai-job-search-dev/ai-job-search: 30.4% reviewed with comments, 0.7% approved with no comment, 68.9% no other review home-assistant/core: 30.3% reviewed with comments, 69.6% approved with no comment, 0.1% no other review libsdl-org/SDL: 30.2% reviewed with comments, 8.5% approved with no comment, 61.3% no other review ollama/ollama: 29.8% reviewed with comments, 60.8% approved with no comment, 9.4% no other review sveltejs/svelte: 29.5% reviewed with comments, 54.4% approved with no comment, 16.1% no other review Jackett/Jackett: 29.4% reviewed with comments, 0.7% approved with no comment, 69.9% no other review vitejs/vite: 29.2% reviewed with comments, 49.2% approved with no comment, 21.6% no other review dataease/dataease: 29.0% reviewed with comments, 0.4% approved with no comment, 70.6% no other review shadps4-emu/shadPS4: 28.8% reviewed with comments, 20.0% approved with no comment, 51.2% no other review jenkinsci/jenkins: 28.0% reviewed with comments, 69.1% approved with no comment, 2.9% no other review ant-design/ant-design: 27.9% reviewed with comments, 71.3% approved with no comment, 0.8% no other review syncthing/syncthing: 27.7% reviewed with comments, 16.9% approved with no comment, 55.4% no other review gofiber/fiber: 27.5% reviewed with comments, 63.3% approved with no comment, 9.2% no other review dmlc/xgboost: 27.3% reviewed with comments, 57.5% approved with no comment, 15.2% no other review spring-projects/spring-boot: 27.0% reviewed with comments, 0.0% approved with no comment, 73.0% no other review starship/starship: 27.0% reviewed with comments, 7.6% approved with no comment, 65.4% no other review cline/cline: 27.0% reviewed with comments, 47.3% approved with no comment, 25.7% no other review pola-rs/polars: 26.7% reviewed with comments, 38.9% approved with no comment, 34.4% no other review Flow-Launcher/Flow.Launcher: 26.6% reviewed with comments, 73.4% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review ggml-org/whisper.cpp: 26.2% reviewed with comments, 62.3% approved with no comment, 11.5% no other review alibaba/nacos: 26.2% reviewed with comments, 31.0% approved with no comment, 42.8% no other review astral-sh/uv: 25.4% reviewed with comments, 26.1% approved with no comment, 48.5% no other review OpenHands/OpenHands: 25.0% reviewed with comments, 58.7% approved with no comment, 16.3% no other review duckdb/duckdb: 24.9% reviewed with comments, 3.0% approved with no comment, 72.1% no other review GoogleChrome/lighthouse: 24.8% reviewed with comments, 33.5% approved with no comment, 41.7% no other review supabase/supabase: 24.8% reviewed with comments, 75.2% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review apache/rocketmq: 24.5% reviewed with comments, 75.5% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review nushell/nushell: 24.4% reviewed with comments, 5.3% approved with no comment, 70.3% no other review scrapy/scrapy: 24.2% reviewed with comments, 72.1% approved with no comment, 3.7% no other review flameshot-org/flameshot: 23.9% reviewed with comments, 20.8% approved with no comment, 55.3% no other review puppeteer/puppeteer: 23.8% reviewed with comments, 76.0% approved with no comment, 0.2% no other review winsiderss/systeminformer: 23.6% reviewed with comments, 65.5% approved with no comment, 10.9% no other review Stirling-Tools/Stirling-PDF: 23.5% reviewed with comments, 75.3% approved with no comment, 1.2% no other review tui-cs/Terminal.Gui: 23.4% reviewed with comments, 33.0% approved with no comment, 43.6% no other review excalidraw/excalidraw: 23.4% reviewed with comments, 27.6% approved with no comment, 49.0% no other review zed-industries/zed: 23.3% reviewed with comments, 37.2% approved with no comment, 39.5% no other review modelcontextprotocol/servers: 23.2% reviewed with comments, 67.5% approved with no comment, 9.3% no other review kestra-io/kestra: 22.9% reviewed with comments, 64.2% approved with no comment, 12.9% no other review icsharpcode/ILSpy: 22.0% reviewed with comments, 10.4% approved with no comment, 67.6% no other review openbq-org/OpenBB: 21.9% reviewed with comments, 78.1% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review heygen-com/hyperframes: 21.9% reviewed with comments, 64.3% approved with no comment, 13.8% no other review microsoft/garnet: 21.3% reviewed with comments, 78.7% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review DioxusLabs/dioxus: 21.1% reviewed with comments, 42.3% approved with no comment, 36.6% no other review Leaflet/Leaflet: 20.9% reviewed with comments, 62.8% approved with no comment, 16.3% no other review conductor-oss/conductor: 20.8% reviewed with comments, 70.4% approved with no comment, 8.8% no other review spring-projects/spring-framework: 20.8% reviewed with comments, 0.0% approved with no comment, 79.2% no other review pnpm/pnpm: 20.8% reviewed with comments, 16.5% approved with no comment, 62.7% no other review Sonarr/Sonarr: 20.5% reviewed with comments, 1.6% approved with no comment, 77.9% no other review denoland/deno: 20.1% reviewed with comments, 42.4% approved with no comment, 37.5% no other review Radarr/Radarr: 19.8% reviewed with comments, 71.6% approved with no comment, 8.6% no other review unslothai/unsloth: 19.5% reviewed with comments, 1.0% approved with no comment, 79.5% no other review openai/codex: 19.5% reviewed with comments, 30.5% approved with no comment, 50.0% no other review gojue/ecapture: 19.4% reviewed with comments, 31.9% approved with no comment, 48.7% no other review Kareadita/Kavita: 19.4% reviewed with comments, 5.2% approved with no comment, 75.4% no other review odysseus-dev/odysseus: 18.4% reviewed with comments, 61.8% approved with no comment, 19.8% no other review infiniflow/ragflow: 18.1% reviewed with comments, 13.5% approved with no comment, 68.4% no other review janhq/jan: 18.0% reviewed with comments, 78.7% approved with no comment, 3.3% no other review oven-sh/bun: 18.0% reviewed with comments, 3.7% approved with no comment, 78.3% no other review preactjs/preact: 17.9% reviewed with comments, 82.1% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review helix-editor/helix: 17.5% reviewed with comments, 57.0% approved with no comment, 25.5% no other review gin-gonic/gin: 17.0% reviewed with comments, 62.0% approved with no comment, 21.0% no other review facebook/rocksdb: 16.8% reviewed with comments, 23.6% approved with no comment, 59.6% no other review Comfy-Org/ComfyUI: 16.8% reviewed with comments, 49.8% approved with no comment, 33.4% no other review zen-browser/desktop: 16.7% reviewed with comments, 18.2% approved with no comment, 65.1% no other review block/buzz: 16.2% reviewed with comments, 40.4% approved with no comment, 43.4% no other review apache/skywalking: 16.0% reviewed with comments, 84.0% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review headroomlabs-ai/headroom: 16.0% reviewed with comments, 47.8% approved with no comment, 36.2% no other review LadybirdBrowser/ladybird: 15.9% reviewed with comments, 15.7% approved with no comment, 68.4% no other review x64dbg/x64dbg: 15.9% reviewed with comments, 0.0% approved with no comment, 84.1% no other review netdata/netdata: 15.7% reviewed with comments, 77.4% approved with no comment, 6.9% no other review microsoft/markitdown: 15.7% reviewed with comments, 2.5% approved with no comment, 81.8% no other review tinyhumansai/openhuman: 15.7% reviewed with comments, 9.1% approved with no comment, 75.2% no other review Fission-AI/OpenSpec: 15.5% reviewed with comments, 63.8% approved with no comment, 20.7% no other review SeleniumHQ/selenium: 15.3% reviewed with comments, 12.1% approved with no comment, 72.6% no other review Mintplex-Labs/anything-llm: 15.2% reviewed with comments, 5.4% approved with no comment, 79.4% no other review XTLS/Xray-core: 15.0% reviewed with comments, 1.1% approved with no comment, 83.9% no other review OtterMind/Chat2DB: 15.0% reviewed with comments, 25.2% approved with no comment, 59.8% no other review MaterialDesignInXAML/MaterialDesignInXamlToolkit: 14.8% reviewed with comments, 35.8% approved with no comment, 49.4% no other review fastapi/fastapi: 14.8% reviewed with comments, 12.4% approved with no comment, 72.8% no other review langgenius/dify: 14.8% reviewed with comments, 85.0% approved with no comment, 0.2% no other review tailwindlabs/tailwindcss: 14.6% reviewed with comments, 35.3% approved with no comment, 50.1% no other review swagger-api/swagger-ui: 14.3% reviewed with comments, 81.1% approved with no comment, 4.6% no other review thingsboard/thingsboard: 14.1% reviewed with comments, 8.6% approved with no comment, 77.3% no other review upstash/context7: 13.8% reviewed with comments, 84.7% approved with no comment, 1.5% no other review herdrdev/herdr: 13.6% reviewed with comments, 5.0% approved with no comment, 81.4% no other review ImageMagick/ImageMagick: 13.5% reviewed with comments, 38.7% approved with no comment, 47.8% no other review coder/code-server: 12.7% reviewed with comments, 82.0% approved with no comment, 5.3% no other review AlistGo/alist: 12.6% reviewed with comments, 87.4% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review apolloconfig/apollo: 12.5% reviewed with comments, 32.1% approved with no comment, 55.4% no other review gethomepage/homepage: 12.5% reviewed with comments, 54.0% approved with no comment, 33.5% no other review usestrix/strix: 12.4% reviewed with comments, 20.7% approved with no comment, 66.9% no other review axios/axios: 12.3% reviewed with comments, 33.0% approved with no comment, 54.7% no other review apache/dubbo: 11.9% reviewed with comments, 88.1% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review prettier/prettier: 11.9% reviewed with comments, 4.7% approved with no comment, 83.4% no other review gatsbyjs/gatsby: 11.8% reviewed with comments, 75.6% approved with no comment, 12.6% no other review anthropics/claude-code: 11.8% reviewed with comments, 88.2% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review OpenAPITools/openapi-generator: 11.5% reviewed with comments, 1.6% approved with no comment, 86.9% no other review microsoft/vscode: 11.5% reviewed with comments, 88.5% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review LizardByte/Sunshine: 11.1% reviewed with comments, 3.7% approved with no comment, 85.2% no other review gogs/gogs: 11.1% reviewed with comments, 24.2% approved with no comment, 64.7% no other review taosdata/TDengine: 10.3% reviewed with comments, 81.1% approved with no comment, 8.6% no other review clash-verge-rev/clash-verge-rev: 10.3% reviewed with comments, 10.8% approved with no comment, 78.9% no other review router-for-me/CLIProxyAPI: 10.2% reviewed with comments, 40.8% approved with no comment, 49.0% no other review DarkFlippers/unleashed-firmware: 9.9% reviewed with comments, 33.7% approved with no comment, 56.4% no other review webpack/webpack: 9.8% reviewed with comments, 19.6% approved with no comment, 70.6% no other review langchain-ai/langchain: 9.8% reviewed with comments, 18.8% approved with no comment, 71.4% no other review toeverything/AFFiNE: 9.3% reviewed with comments, 40.2% approved with no comment, 50.5% no other review Devolutions/UniGetUI: 8.9% reviewed with comments, 68.9% approved with no comment, 22.2% no other review radareorg/radare2: 8.6% reviewed with comments, 0.1% approved with no comment, 91.3% no other review halo-dev/halo: 8.6% reviewed with comments, 45.4% approved with no comment, 46.0% no other review aseprite/aseprite: 8.5% reviewed with comments, 6.8% approved with no comment, 84.7% no other review usememos/memos: 8.3% reviewed with comments, 50.5% approved with no comment, 41.2% no other review shadcn-ui/ui: 8.1% reviewed with comments, 18.6% approved with no comment, 73.3% no other review abpframework/abp: 7.8% reviewed with comments, 89.6% approved with no comment, 2.6% no other review drawdb-io/drawdb: 7.8% reviewed with comments, 53.3% approved with no comment, 38.9% no other review Egonex-AI/Understand-Anything: 7.6% reviewed with comments, 3.0% approved with no comment, 89.4% no other review immerjs/immer: 7.3% reviewed with comments, 1.2% approved with no comment, 91.5% no other review photoprism/photoprism: 7.1% reviewed with comments, 0.9% approved with no comment, 92.0% no other review microsoft/monaco-editor: 7.1% reviewed with comments, 92.9% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review NationalSecurityAgency/ghidra: 6.8% reviewed with comments, 4.5% approved with no comment, 88.7% no other review NousResearch/hermes-agent: 6.8% reviewed with comments, 5.0% approved with no comment, 88.2% no other review vercel-labs/agent-browser: 6.8% reviewed with comments, 10.7% approved with no comment, 82.5% no other review facebookresearch/faiss: 6.6% reviewed with comments, 0.3% approved with no comment, 93.1% no other review QuantConnect/Lean: 6.4% reviewed with comments, 63.7% approved with no comment, 29.9% no other review ReactiveX/RxJava: 6.4% reviewed with comments, 36.0% approved with no comment, 57.6% no other review sumatrapdfreader/sumatrapdf: 6.3% reviewed with comments, 0.0% approved with no comment, 93.7% no other review App-vNext/Polly: 6.1% reviewed with comments, 64.2% approved with no comment, 29.7% no other review facebook/docusaurus: 6.1% reviewed with comments, 7.5% approved with no comment, 86.4% no other review hashcat/hashcat: 6.0% reviewed with comments, 1.2% approved with no comment, 92.8% no other review opendataloader-project/opendataloader-pdf: 6.0% reviewed with comments, 51.7% approved with no comment, 42.3% no other review rustfs/rustfs: 6.0% reviewed with comments, 19.0% approved with no comment, 75.0% no other review earendil-works/pi: 6.0% reviewed with comments, 2.0% approved with no comment, 92.0% no other review nestjs/nest: 6.0% reviewed with comments, 2.2% approved with no comment, 91.8% no other review HandBrake/HandBrake: 5.5% reviewed with comments, 0.0% approved with no comment, 94.5% no other review react/react-native: 5.5% reviewed with comments, 17.4% approved with no comment, 77.1% no other review commaai/openpilot: 5.5% reviewed with comments, 0.1% approved with no comment, 94.4% no other review protocolbuffers/protobuf: 5.2% reviewed with comments, 3.3% approved with no comment, 91.5% no other review gohugoio/hugo: 5.2% reviewed with comments, 1.3% approved with no comment, 93.5% no other review alibaba/arthas: 5.1% reviewed with comments, 2.6% approved with no comment, 92.3% no other review storytold/photocraft: 5.0% reviewed with comments, 0.2% approved with no comment, 94.8% no other review QuantumNous/new-api: 4.6% reviewed with comments, 19.4% approved with no comment, 76.0% no other review zellij-org/zellij: 4.4% reviewed with comments, 0.7% approved with no comment, 94.9% no other review anomalyco/opencode: 4.4% reviewed with comments, 1.8% approved with no comment, 93.8% no other review babalae/better-genshin-impact: 4.3% reviewed with comments, 1.7% approved with no comment, 94.0% no other review telegramdesktop/tdesktop: 4.3% reviewed with comments, 2.1% approved with no comment, 93.6% no other review paperclipai/paperclip: 3.7% reviewed with comments, 5.6% approved with no comment, 90.7% no other review semgrep/semgrep: 3.6% reviewed with comments, 90.5% approved with no comment, 5.9% no other review multica-ai/multica: 3.6% reviewed with comments, 6.0% approved with no comment, 90.4% no other review firecrawl/firecrawl: 3.5% reviewed with comments, 27.4% approved with no comment, 69.1% no other review sandboxie-plus/Sandboxie: 3.3% reviewed with comments, 0.0% approved with no comment, 96.7% no other review coturn/coturn: 3.1% reviewed with comments, 6.9% approved with no comment, 90.0% no other review CoplayDev/unity-mcp: 3.1% reviewed with comments, 0.6% approved with no comment, 96.3% no other review apache/shardingsphere: 2.9% reviewed with comments, 97.1% approved with no comment, 0.0% no other review codewhale-hq/Codewhale: 2.9% reviewed with comments, 2.7% approved with no comment, 94.4% no other review lobehub/lobehub: 2.9% reviewed with comments, 7.6% approved with no comment, 89.5% no other review ossrs/srs: 2.7% reviewed with comments, 17.3% approved with no comment, 80.0% no other review ultraworkers/claw-code: 2.7% reviewed with comments, 0.0% approved with no comment, 97.3% no other review webtorrent/webtorrent: 2.6% reviewed with comments, 75.3% approved with no comment, 22.1% no other review tensorflow/tensorflow: 2.2% reviewed with comments, 4.1% approved with no comment, 93.7% no other review browser-use/browser-use: 2.1% reviewed with comments, 5.5% approved with no comment, 92.4% no other review duplicati/duplicati: 2.0% reviewed with comments, 2.7% approved with no comment, 95.3% no other review mybatis/mybatis-3: 1.9% reviewed with comments, 9.6% approved with no comment, 88.5% no other review nocodb/nocodb: 1.7% reviewed with comments, 98.2% approved with no comment, 0.1% no other review remotion-dev/remotion: 1.7% reviewed with comments, 0.9% approved with no comment, 97.4% no other review spacedriveapp/spacedrive: 1.6% reviewed with comments, 2.5% approved with no comment, 95.9% no other review mRemoteNG/mRemoteNG: 1.4% reviewed with comments, 2.5% approved with no comment, 96.1% no other review lysine-dev/retrofit: 1.3% reviewed with comments, 3.3% approved with no comment, 95.4% no other review stablyai/orca: 1.3% reviewed with comments, 2.4% approved with no comment, 96.3% no other review oracle/graal: 1.1% reviewed with comments, 0.2% approved with no comment, 98.7% no other review SubtitleEdit/subtitleedit: 0.9% reviewed with comments, 0.5% approved with no comment, 98.6% no other review cheaper-inference/OmniRoute: 0.7% reviewed with comments, 0.3% approved with no comment, 99.0% no other review iOfficeAI/OfficeCLI: 0.0% reviewed with comments, 12.1% approved with no comment, 87.9% no other review peass-ng/PEASS-ng: 0.0% reviewed with comments, 0.0% approved with no comment, 100.0% no other review QL-Win/QuickLook: 0.0% reviewed with comments, 16.7% approved with no comment, 83.3% no other review facebook/folly: 0.0% reviewed with comments, 10.0% approved with no comment, 90.0% no other review The-Vibe-Company/quivr: 0.0% reviewed with comments, 0.0% approved with no comment, 100.0% no other review google/guava: 0.0% reviewed with comments, 1.0% approved with no comment, 99.0% no other review opendatalab/MinerU: 0.0% reviewed with comments, 0.4% approved with no comment, 99.6% no other review storybookjs/storybook: 0.0% reviewed with comments, 8.7% approved with no comment, 91.3% no other review Median repo: 26% ← Most discussed Least discussed →
Repos owned by an organization, with 30 or more merged PRs we could read reviews for. In the median one, 26% of merged PRs were reviewed with comments by someone other than the author, so 74% got no review comments from another person. Hover a column to see the repo.
Each column is the median repo’s share, so a row doesn’t add up to 100%.
For the 160 repos with 30 or more AI-signed PRs and 30 or more others in the 12 months, we compared each repo’s AI PRs with its own other PRs, state by state, then took the median of the gaps.
There’s no sign that reviewers go easier on AI PRs. If anything, AI PRs get commented on a little more.
AI PRs are bigger: in the median one of these 160 repos, the typical AI PR is 1.6× the size of the typical other PR, and it’s bigger in 124 of them. Bigger PRs draw more comments, which may be all this is. The point is what isn’t there: AI PRs aren’t merged unreviewed or approved silently more often.
If a silently approved PR is one nobody really read, you’d expect more of them to need a fix. In the six languages coderot reads, we compared PRs approved with no human comment with PRs reviewed with comments, within each repo: how many had their lines fixed within 30 days?
That isn’t a sign that silent approval works. Most of it is size. Commented PRs are 3.3× as big as silently approved ones in the median repo, and a bigger PR has more lines a later fix can land on. So we split the PRs by size:
Fixed later: silently approved PRs against commented ones, by size 0–20 lines: median −0.1 pts; 21–100 lines: median −0.9 pts; 101–400 lines: median −1.8 pts; Over 400 lines: median −6.9 pts Fixed later: silently approved PRs against commented ones, by size Each dot is a repo. Left of 0: its silently approved PRs were fixed later less often. −40 −20 0 +20 +40 0–20 lines 101 repos aaif-goose/goose: 1.4% of 648 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 5.2% of 154 commented ones alibaba/open-code-review: 5.3% of 94 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 4.0% of 50 commented ones angular/angular: 1.6% of 64 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.7% of 1148 commented ones anomalyco/opencode: 9.8% of 41 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 13.0% of 69 commented ones ansible/ansible: 0.0% of 73 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 32 commented ones ant-design/ant-design: 1.7% of 780 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 4.2% of 216 commented ones apache/superset: 0.7% of 2051 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 1.2% of 412 commented ones aquasecurity/trivy: 0.0% of 138 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 58 commented ones astral-sh/ruff: 0.3% of 351 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 179 commented ones astral-sh/uv: 0.6% of 312 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.7% of 137 commented ones AvaloniaUI/Avalonia: 0.0% of 136 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 5.2% of 58 commented ones bevyengine/bevy: 0.3% of 611 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 3.2% of 253 commented ones bitwarden/server: 0.7% of 449 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 44 commented ones block/buzz: 3.9% of 233 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 2.9% of 34 commented ones bytedance/deer-flow: 3.3% of 242 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 6.7% of 89 commented ones cli/cli: 0.5% of 220 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 1.4% of 71 commented ones cline/cline: 5.4% of 354 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 12.3% of 81 commented ones Comfy-Org/ComfyUI: 1.2% of 512 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 8.1% of 86 commented ones dani-garcia/vaultwarden: 3.2% of 63 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 3.3% of 30 commented ones denoland/deno: 5.2% of 306 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 2.2% of 46 commented ones django/django: 0.0% of 174 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.7% of 140 commented ones docker/compose: 0.0% of 185 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 47 commented ones docling-project/docling: 3.3% of 153 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 1.8% of 55 commented ones dotnet/aspnetcore: 0.0% of 392 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.7% of 145 commented ones dotnet/efcore: 0.0% of 169 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 38 commented ones dotnet/maui: 0.0% of 89 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 58 commented ones dotnet/roslyn: 0.0% of 276 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 2.2% of 134 commented ones dotnet/runtime: 0.0% of 965 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.1% of 903 commented ones etcd-io/etcd: 0.0% of 64 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 186 commented ones ethereum/go-ethereum: 0.0% of 319 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 113 commented ones farion1231/cc-switch: 11.8% of 34 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 6.0% of 50 commented ones fastify/fastify: 0.0% of 94 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 48 commented ones files-community/Files: 1.9% of 53 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 36 commented ones firecracker-microvm/firecracker: 0.0% of 114 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 2.2% of 45 commented ones freeCodeCamp/freeCodeCamp: 0.4% of 1308 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.2% of 554 commented ones gchq/CyberChef: 0.0% of 144 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 45 commented ones github/spec-kit: 0.8% of 125 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 113 commented ones go-gitea/gitea: 2.2% of 268 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 1.7% of 176 commented ones google-gemini/gemini-cli: 2.4% of 544 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 6.9% of 159 commented ones grafana/grafana: 0.3% of 2652 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 1.1% of 465 commented ones headroomlabs-ai/headroom: 2.6% of 117 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 34 commented ones helix-editor/helix: 0.0% of 180 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 34 commented ones heygen-com/hyperframes: 7.7% of 183 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 11.1% of 45 commented ones home-assistant/core: 0.3% of 5874 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 1.4% of 996 commented ones huggingface/transformers: 1.8% of 564 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 2.6% of 506 commented ones immich-app/immich: 0.6% of 962 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.8% of 242 commented ones infiniflow/ragflow: 6.3% of 176 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 9.8% of 214 commented ones istio/istio: 2.1% of 96 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 139 commented ones jellyfin/jellyfin: 1.6% of 247 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 59 commented ones juspay/hyperswitch: 0.7% of 279 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 3.6% of 84 commented ones keras-team/keras: 2.7% of 224 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 3.5% of 86 commented ones kubernetes/kubernetes: 0.0% of 62 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 1.1% of 447 commented ones langchain-ai/langchain: 0.7% of 147 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 33 commented ones langgenius/dify: 2.3% of 1299 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 5.6% of 125 commented ones louislam/uptime-kuma: 0.0% of 32 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 5.4% of 37 commented ones mem0ai/mem0: 2.1% of 143 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 2.6% of 39 commented ones microsoft/playwright: 2.2% of 835 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 3.8% of 130 commented ones microsoft/vscode: 2.8% of 4860 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 4.9% of 407 commented ones milvus-io/milvus: 2.9% of 105 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 1.4% of 146 commented ones moby/moby: 0.0% of 576 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 197 commented ones mozilla/pdf.js: 0.0% of 177 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 202 commented ones mrdoob/three.js: 0.6% of 155 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.9% of 116 commented ones mui/material-ui: 0.2% of 575 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 2.0% of 98 commented ones n8n-io/n8n: 1.9% of 1315 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 2.5% of 158 commented ones netdata/netdata: 0.0% of 631 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 119 commented ones nexu-io/open-design: 6.3% of 112 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 6.7% of 252 commented ones nodejs/node: 0.0% of 746 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 359 commented ones ollama/ollama: 2.5% of 161 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 30 commented ones openai/codex: 3.3% of 736 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 4.6% of 131 commented ones OpenHands/OpenHands: 3.1% of 418 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 1.1% of 90 commented ones paperclipai/paperclip: 1.4% of 148 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 1.2% of 82 commented ones pingcap/tidb: 0.0% of 156 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 189 commented ones pnpm/pnpm: 2.0% of 151 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 4.8% of 42 commented ones pola-rs/polars: 1.4% of 293 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 1.9% of 106 commented ones PowerShell/PowerShell: 0.0% of 121 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 30 commented ones ppy/osu: 2.4% of 170 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 5.6% of 107 commented ones prometheus/prometheus: 0.0% of 438 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 103 commented ones puppeteer/puppeteer: 14.3% of 363 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 2.3% of 44 commented ones python/cpython: 0.0% of 309 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 598 commented ones pytorch/pytorch: 1.3% of 1743 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 3.4% of 2730 commented ones rclone/rclone: 0.0% of 125 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 47 commented ones rustfs/rustfs: 3.3% of 153 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 2.6% of 38 commented ones scikit-learn/scikit-learn: 0.0% of 224 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.6% of 174 commented ones servo/servo: 0.1% of 861 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.6% of 532 commented ones shadcn-ui/ui: 2.3% of 129 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 47 commented ones Significant-Gravitas/AutoGPT: 1.3% of 156 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 1.2% of 83 commented ones Stirling-Tools/Stirling-PDF: 0.4% of 522 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 41 commented ones strapi/strapi: 1.0% of 288 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 2.7% of 75 commented ones supabase/supabase: 2.4% of 1716 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 3.9% of 228 commented ones sveltejs/svelte: 4.4% of 114 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 5.1% of 39 commented ones tailscale/tailscale: 0.0% of 114 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 51 commented ones tauri-apps/tauri: 0.7% of 140 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 66 commented ones tinyhumansai/openhuman: 7.5% of 40 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 6.1% of 33 commented ones usebruno/bruno: 4.4% of 248 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 9.3% of 43 commented ones vercel/next.js: 1.1% of 696 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 1.2% of 249 commented ones vitejs/vite: 1.6% of 306 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 3.5% of 115 commented ones vllm-project/vllm: 1.9% of 1910 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 3.1% of 1892 commented ones warpdotdev/warp: 1.0% of 490 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 2.1% of 95 commented ones withastro/astro: 1.2% of 425 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.9% of 106 commented ones yt-dlp/yt-dlp: 0.0% of 67 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 66 commented ones zed-industries/zed: 1.1% of 944 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 2.6% of 346 commented ones 0–20 lines: median −0.1 pts median −0.1 pts 21–100 lines 106 repos aaif-goose/goose: 7.4% of 502 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 7.8% of 255 commented ones alibaba/open-code-review: 4.8% of 105 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 3.9% of 51 commented ones anomalyco/opencode: 20.6% of 34 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 24.3% of 74 commented ones ansible/ansible: 2.9% of 34 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 73 commented ones ant-design/ant-design: 4.0% of 252 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 5.9% of 136 commented ones apache/superset: 7.2% of 638 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 7.2% of 446 commented ones aquasecurity/trivy: 1.7% of 58 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 1.7% of 59 commented ones astral-sh/ruff: 1.9% of 468 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 3.2% of 505 commented ones astral-sh/uv: 0.8% of 241 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 2.3% of 221 commented ones AvaloniaUI/Avalonia: 1.4% of 147 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 2.5% of 121 commented ones bevyengine/bevy: 2.7% of 292 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 1.9% of 365 commented ones bitwarden/server: 1.4% of 215 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 1.6% of 61 commented ones block/buzz: 14.8% of 230 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 10.0% of 30 commented ones bytedance/deer-flow: 11.5% of 347 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 16.3% of 307 commented ones caddyserver/caddy: 0.0% of 60 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 76 commented ones cli/cli: 3.3% of 61 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 36 commented ones cline/cline: 9.3% of 322 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 17.1% of 146 commented ones code-yeongyu/oh-my-openagent: 35.3% of 34 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 35.4% of 48 commented ones Comfy-Org/ComfyUI: 3.0% of 197 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 4.9% of 81 commented ones dani-garcia/vaultwarden: 2.9% of 34 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 6.5% of 31 commented ones denoland/deno: 11.0% of 456 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 18.5% of 157 commented ones django/django: 1.5% of 65 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 2.2% of 226 commented ones docker/compose: 1.6% of 61 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 3.3% of 30 commented ones docling-project/docling: 11.8% of 186 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 18.9% of 90 commented ones dotnet/aspnetcore: 2.1% of 142 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 3.1% of 130 commented ones dotnet/BenchmarkDotNet: 3.2% of 31 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 2.2% of 46 commented ones dotnet/efcore: 0.9% of 107 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 72 commented ones dotnet/maui: 0.0% of 58 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 1.9% of 54 commented ones dotnet/roslyn: 1.4% of 218 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 1.5% of 202 commented ones dotnet/runtime: 0.3% of 591 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 1.2% of 1101 commented ones etcd-io/etcd: 0.0% of 33 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 106 commented ones ethereum/go-ethereum: 0.0% of 106 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 81 commented ones farion1231/cc-switch: 5.7% of 35 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 20.7% of 82 commented ones fastify/fastify: 0.0% of 47 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 2.7% of 37 commented ones files-community/Files: 0.0% of 44 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 1.8% of 56 commented ones firecracker-microvm/firecracker: 0.0% of 55 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 3.2% of 62 commented ones freeCodeCamp/freeCodeCamp: 0.9% of 332 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 3.0% of 201 commented ones gchq/CyberChef: 0.0% of 52 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 5.3% of 38 commented ones github/spec-kit: 0.0% of 101 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.9% of 217 commented ones go-gitea/gitea: 4.1% of 221 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 6.0% of 300 commented ones gofiber/fiber: 2.6% of 76 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 36 commented ones google-gemini/gemini-cli: 13.2% of 508 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 13.4% of 284 commented ones grafana/grafana: 1.1% of 1880 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 1.2% of 822 commented ones headroomlabs-ai/headroom: 9.5% of 337 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 14.5% of 83 commented ones heygen-com/hyperframes: 18.1% of 626 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 25.4% of 126 commented ones home-assistant/core: 1.3% of 3117 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 3.5% of 1232 commented ones huggingface/transformers: 3.3% of 245 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 4.4% of 590 commented ones immich-app/immich: 3.2% of 411 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 1.6% of 245 commented ones infiniflow/ragflow: 14.6% of 246 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 23.4% of 286 commented ones istio/istio: 0.0% of 104 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.7% of 143 commented ones jellyfin/jellyfin: 0.0% of 79 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 4.6% of 65 commented ones juspay/hyperswitch: 6.2% of 258 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 5.7% of 209 commented ones keras-team/keras: 3.9% of 257 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 8.8% of 205 commented ones langchain-ai/langchain: 4.8% of 165 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 6.1% of 49 commented ones langgenius/dify: 5.8% of 1535 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 6.4% of 202 commented ones mem0ai/mem0: 4.3% of 140 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 6.9% of 116 commented ones microsoft/playwright: 7.1% of 547 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 12.2% of 279 commented ones microsoft/TypeScript: 1.6% of 61 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 2.9% of 35 commented ones microsoft/vscode: 6.1% of 3714 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 9.0% of 478 commented ones milvus-io/milvus: 8.9% of 79 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 5.9% of 188 commented ones moby/moby: 0.0% of 185 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 150 commented ones mozilla/pdf.js: 1.3% of 155 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 1.4% of 287 commented ones mrdoob/three.js: 0.0% of 61 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.7% of 134 commented ones mui/material-ui: 0.6% of 158 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.8% of 126 commented ones n8n-io/n8n: 5.6% of 1562 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 6.5% of 443 commented ones netdata/netdata: 0.6% of 321 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 110 commented ones nexu-io/open-design: 9.6% of 188 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 16.5% of 448 commented ones nodejs/node: 0.0% of 407 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.5% of 419 commented ones NousResearch/hermes-agent: 17.5% of 80 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 34.9% of 86 commented ones ollama/ollama: 1.3% of 152 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 47 commented ones openai/codex: 9.4% of 843 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 12.9% of 309 commented ones OpenHands/OpenHands: 8.3% of 338 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 6.9% of 87 commented ones oven-sh/bun: 0.0% of 59 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 1.2% of 167 commented ones pingcap/tidb: 0.0% of 153 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 274 commented ones pnpm/pnpm: 10.8% of 186 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 15.7% of 140 commented ones pola-rs/polars: 2.7% of 329 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 3.7% of 187 commented ones PowerShell/PowerShell: 0.0% of 35 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 35 commented ones ppy/osu: 5.6% of 142 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 6.1% of 132 commented ones prometheus/prometheus: 0.6% of 169 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 130 commented ones puppeteer/puppeteer: 7.6% of 118 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 13.2% of 68 commented ones python/cpython: 0.0% of 145 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 548 commented ones pytorch/pytorch: 5.2% of 1718 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 9.8% of 3204 commented ones rclone/rclone: 0.0% of 90 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 48 commented ones react/react: 1.9% of 103 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 4.8% of 42 commented ones rtk-ai/rtk: 25.6% of 43 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 25.9% of 54 commented ones rustfs/rustfs: 18.1% of 227 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 32.6% of 46 commented ones scikit-learn/scikit-learn: 0.0% of 79 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.9% of 218 commented ones scrapy/scrapy: 0.5% of 189 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 1.8% of 56 commented ones servo/servo: 0.0% of 692 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 665 commented ones Significant-Gravitas/AutoGPT: 13.2% of 144 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 17.7% of 79 commented ones Stirling-Tools/Stirling-PDF: 3.4% of 293 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 3.6% of 55 commented ones strapi/strapi: 4.3% of 139 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 4.8% of 84 commented ones supabase/supabase: 7.4% of 1058 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 6.5% of 308 commented ones sveltejs/svelte: 11.1% of 208 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 12.7% of 110 commented ones tailscale/tailscale: 0.0% of 69 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 94 commented ones tauri-apps/tauri: 12.0% of 75 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 2.6% of 76 commented ones tinyhumansai/openhuman: 22.1% of 86 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 14.3% of 91 commented ones usebruno/bruno: 12.4% of 218 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 4.7% of 64 commented ones vercel/next.js: 2.4% of 666 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 1.7% of 346 commented ones vitejs/vite: 15.0% of 127 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 8.9% of 112 commented ones vllm-project/vllm: 3.2% of 1128 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 5.5% of 2214 commented ones warpdotdev/warp: 5.8% of 365 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 8.4% of 191 commented ones webpack/webpack: 7.5% of 106 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 11.1% of 36 commented ones withastro/astro: 4.3% of 394 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 10.4% of 192 commented ones yt-dlp/yt-dlp: 9.3% of 43 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 6.0% of 67 commented ones zed-industries/zed: 2.6% of 823 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 4.8% of 499 commented ones 21–100 lines: median −0.9 pts median −0.9 pts 101–400 lines 95 repos aaif-goose/goose: 16.5% of 393 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 15.1% of 272 commented ones alibaba/open-code-review: 14.9% of 67 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 13.3% of 90 commented ones angular/angular: 23.5% of 34 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 8.6% of 544 commented ones ant-design/ant-design: 6.4% of 94 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 10.3% of 68 commented ones apache/superset: 14.3% of 491 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 15.3% of 600 commented ones astral-sh/ruff: 4.5% of 357 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 5.2% of 748 commented ones astral-sh/uv: 3.0% of 197 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 3.1% of 255 commented ones AvaloniaUI/Avalonia: 1.2% of 84 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 4.4% of 113 commented ones bevyengine/bevy: 5.5% of 127 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 7.4% of 349 commented ones bitwarden/server: 3.6% of 195 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 2.5% of 157 commented ones block/buzz: 27.3% of 289 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 27.1% of 107 commented ones bytedance/deer-flow: 23.2% of 297 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 29.4% of 695 commented ones cline/cline: 16.6% of 290 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 20.8% of 178 commented ones code-yeongyu/oh-my-openagent: 47.2% of 36 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 32.7% of 55 commented ones Comfy-Org/ComfyUI: 15.3% of 150 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 17.6% of 68 commented ones denoland/deno: 18.4% of 332 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 22.6% of 226 commented ones docker/compose: 7.9% of 38 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 11.9% of 42 commented ones docling-project/docling: 26.9% of 130 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 19.8% of 86 commented ones dotnet/aspnetcore: 2.6% of 76 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 5.3% of 150 commented ones dotnet/efcore: 0.0% of 99 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 1.8% of 109 commented ones dotnet/maui: 2.0% of 51 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 2.7% of 75 commented ones dotnet/roslyn: 0.9% of 114 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 3.5% of 259 commented ones dotnet/runtime: 0.9% of 336 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 1.8% of 999 commented ones ethereum/go-ethereum: 0.0% of 55 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 92 commented ones farion1231/cc-switch: 23.5% of 34 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 21.2% of 99 commented ones Fission-AI/OpenSpec: 24.0% of 121 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 19.4% of 36 commented ones freeCodeCamp/freeCodeCamp: 3.3% of 210 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 1.7% of 173 commented ones go-gitea/gitea: 14.9% of 101 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 13.1% of 350 commented ones gofiber/fiber: 0.0% of 46 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 1.8% of 55 commented ones google-gemini/gemini-cli: 17.5% of 462 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 20.6% of 509 commented ones grafana/grafana: 1.5% of 1523 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 2.1% of 1358 commented ones hashicorp/terraform: 2.5% of 79 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 3.3% of 61 commented ones headroomlabs-ai/headroom: 23.9% of 389 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 34.1% of 123 commented ones heygen-com/hyperframes: 40.9% of 817 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 46.1% of 267 commented ones home-assistant/core: 2.2% of 1797 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 5.1% of 1613 commented ones hoppscotch/hoppscotch: 9.1% of 33 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 16.7% of 30 commented ones huggingface/transformers: 8.1% of 86 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 13.9% of 409 commented ones immich-app/immich: 4.8% of 228 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 5.2% of 229 commented ones infiniflow/ragflow: 21.1% of 227 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 36.7% of 281 commented ones istio/istio: 2.1% of 47 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 2.8% of 177 commented ones janhq/jan: 21.7% of 106 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 13.3% of 30 commented ones jellyfin/jellyfin: 5.5% of 55 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 10.5% of 57 commented ones juspay/hyperswitch: 7.1% of 170 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 8.3% of 336 commented ones keras-team/keras: 4.1% of 123 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 7.9% of 126 commented ones langchain-ai/langchain: 2.5% of 80 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 12.0% of 75 commented ones langflow-ai/langflow: 9.8% of 61 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 15.9% of 44 commented ones langgenius/dify: 14.4% of 1370 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 11.5% of 243 commented ones mem0ai/mem0: 6.4% of 125 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 17.4% of 69 commented ones microsoft/playwright: 11.6% of 268 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 21.7% of 235 commented ones microsoft/semantic-kernel: 0.0% of 35 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 32 commented ones microsoft/TypeScript: 0.0% of 66 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 2.2% of 46 commented ones microsoft/vscode: 11.6% of 3314 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 15.9% of 459 commented ones milvus-io/milvus: 2.4% of 85 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 9.4% of 320 commented ones moby/moby: 1.7% of 60 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 2.1% of 94 commented ones mozilla/pdf.js: 4.3% of 46 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 3.7% of 164 commented ones mui/material-ui: 8.2% of 49 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 6.1% of 115 commented ones multica-ai/multica: 21.6% of 88 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 25.0% of 44 commented ones n8n-io/n8n: 11.2% of 1607 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 13.6% of 1064 commented ones netdata/netdata: 1.8% of 271 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 59 commented ones nexu-io/open-design: 20.6% of 204 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 23.7% of 704 commented ones nodejs/node: 0.0% of 156 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.8% of 245 commented ones NousResearch/hermes-agent: 39.3% of 107 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 43.6% of 140 commented ones ollama/ollama: 0.0% of 133 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 4.0% of 75 commented ones openai/codex: 14.7% of 990 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 18.9% of 710 commented ones OpenHands/OpenHands: 14.2% of 339 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 17.7% of 147 commented ones oven-sh/bun: 0.0% of 57 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.7% of 291 commented ones pingcap/tidb: 0.0% of 145 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 307 commented ones pnpm/pnpm: 38.7% of 186 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 40.5% of 304 commented ones pola-rs/polars: 10.0% of 180 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 11.7% of 179 commented ones ppy/osu: 7.9% of 38 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 15.2% of 99 commented ones prometheus/prometheus: 0.0% of 66 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 2.7% of 149 commented ones puppeteer/puppeteer: 3.1% of 64 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 17.1% of 41 commented ones python/cpython: 0.0% of 31 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 229 commented ones pytorch/pytorch: 10.7% of 913 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 16.9% of 2558 commented ones react/react: 1.0% of 98 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 4.2% of 71 commented ones rustfs/rustfs: 36.8% of 334 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 37.2% of 78 commented ones scikit-learn/scikit-learn: 0.0% of 31 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 4.8% of 126 commented ones scrapy/scrapy: 2.8% of 141 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 1.6% of 63 commented ones servo/servo: 0.7% of 437 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 1.0% of 628 commented ones Significant-Gravitas/AutoGPT: 18.9% of 148 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 21.6% of 148 commented ones stablyai/orca: 41.0% of 117 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 36.2% of 58 commented ones Stirling-Tools/Stirling-PDF: 7.1% of 241 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 7.0% of 86 commented ones strapi/strapi: 11.0% of 136 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 7.6% of 172 commented ones supabase/supabase: 15.2% of 907 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 19.8% of 464 commented ones sveltejs/svelte: 19.7% of 61 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 11.8% of 51 commented ones tailscale/tailscale: 0.0% of 35 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.7% of 136 commented ones tinyhumansai/openhuman: 31.8% of 154 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 32.7% of 245 commented ones usebruno/bruno: 26.7% of 172 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 26.0% of 154 commented ones vercel/next.js: 5.6% of 630 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 7.7% of 574 commented ones vitejs/vite: 15.2% of 46 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 15.4% of 52 commented ones vllm-project/vllm: 6.7% of 594 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 9.6% of 2085 commented ones warpdotdev/warp: 9.9% of 382 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 8.9% of 314 commented ones webpack/webpack: 21.6% of 97 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 29.7% of 64 commented ones withastro/astro: 4.8% of 248 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 15.3% of 196 commented ones zed-industries/zed: 6.6% of 712 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 6.3% of 585 commented ones 101–400 lines: median −1.8 pts median −1.8 pts Over 400 lines 72 repos aaif-goose/goose: 28.4% of 341 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 48.7% of 302 commented ones alibaba/open-code-review: 29.8% of 57 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 36.8% of 68 commented ones ant-design/ant-design: 6.8% of 44 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 8.1% of 37 commented ones apache/superset: 26.4% of 258 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 35.7% of 594 commented ones astral-sh/ruff: 11.6% of 121 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 13.9% of 567 commented ones astral-sh/uv: 6.4% of 94 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 6.2% of 209 commented ones AvaloniaUI/Avalonia: 10.0% of 30 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 15.0% of 107 commented ones bevyengine/bevy: 0.0% of 38 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 22.1% of 240 commented ones bitwarden/server: 6.2% of 130 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 11.6% of 268 commented ones block/buzz: 50.6% of 433 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 54.4% of 305 commented ones bytedance/deer-flow: 38.0% of 92 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 56.3% of 602 commented ones cline/cline: 44.9% of 167 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 47.7% of 241 commented ones Comfy-Org/ComfyUI: 11.5% of 78 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 35.8% of 81 commented ones denoland/deno: 37.2% of 113 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 45.5% of 143 commented ones docling-project/docling: 26.3% of 80 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 38.7% of 75 commented ones dotnet/aspnetcore: 4.7% of 86 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 7.1% of 156 commented ones dotnet/efcore: 0.0% of 45 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 3.5% of 86 commented ones dotnet/maui: 3.6% of 56 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 6.9% of 116 commented ones dotnet/roslyn: 7.9% of 63 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 6.9% of 248 commented ones dotnet/runtime: 1.6% of 122 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 7.5% of 827 commented ones Fission-AI/OpenSpec: 52.5% of 59 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 52.5% of 40 commented ones freeCodeCamp/freeCodeCamp: 4.2% of 95 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 5.6% of 179 commented ones FuelLabs/sway: 5.7% of 35 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 7.3% of 41 commented ones go-gitea/gitea: 23.9% of 46 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 24.7% of 162 commented ones google-gemini/gemini-cli: 31.4% of 226 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 44.0% of 436 commented ones grafana/grafana: 1.8% of 621 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 3.5% of 1406 commented ones headroomlabs-ai/headroom: 39.0% of 154 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 55.9% of 93 commented ones heygen-com/hyperframes: 62.2% of 693 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 68.2% of 352 commented ones home-assistant/core: 5.1% of 641 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 11.8% of 1129 commented ones huggingface/transformers: 18.0% of 61 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 43.6% of 424 commented ones immich-app/immich: 12.8% of 141 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 18.1% of 144 commented ones infiniflow/ragflow: 54.0% of 124 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 57.9% of 254 commented ones janhq/jan: 45.5% of 121 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 51.2% of 41 commented ones juspay/hyperswitch: 9.8% of 92 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 23.1% of 399 commented ones langflow-ai/langflow: 16.3% of 86 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 28.7% of 80 commented ones langgenius/dify: 35.2% of 1248 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 32.5% of 382 commented ones mem0ai/mem0: 27.8% of 97 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 40.0% of 70 commented ones microsoft/garnet: 8.1% of 62 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 23.6% of 55 commented ones microsoft/playwright: 25.4% of 138 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 42.0% of 150 commented ones microsoft/TypeScript: 3.6% of 55 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 14.4% of 90 commented ones microsoft/vscode: 24.3% of 2046 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 32.8% of 475 commented ones milvus-io/milvus: 13.3% of 75 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 29.4% of 585 commented ones multica-ai/multica: 37.2% of 86 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 50.0% of 66 commented ones n8n-io/n8n: 30.9% of 1076 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 34.9% of 2011 commented ones netdata/netdata: 13.3% of 528 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 10.3% of 68 commented ones nexu-io/open-design: 40.8% of 142 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 47.7% of 813 commented ones nodejs/node: 0.0% of 101 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.7% of 134 commented ones NousResearch/hermes-agent: 73.5% of 68 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 83.1% of 160 commented ones ollama/ollama: 5.2% of 97 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 6.1% of 114 commented ones openai/codex: 28.5% of 582 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 36.6% of 865 commented ones OpenHands/OpenHands: 22.6% of 226 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 35.3% of 238 commented ones pingcap/tidb: 0.0% of 79 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 291 commented ones pnpm/pnpm: 67.0% of 94 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 73.5% of 291 commented ones pola-rs/polars: 29.4% of 68 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 42.7% of 124 commented ones pytorch/pytorch: 14.9% of 328 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 24.9% of 1343 commented ones react/react: 5.9% of 34 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 15.6% of 45 commented ones rustfs/rustfs: 63.7% of 259 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 73.6% of 144 commented ones servo/servo: 0.0% of 102 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 2.4% of 255 commented ones Significant-Gravitas/AutoGPT: 44.8% of 163 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 57.7% of 390 commented ones stablyai/orca: 71.6% of 109 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 79.3% of 87 commented ones Stirling-Tools/Stirling-PDF: 25.4% of 343 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 26.0% of 254 commented ones strapi/strapi: 5.3% of 57 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 30.6% of 173 commented ones supabase/supabase: 28.4% of 617 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 38.8% of 420 commented ones tinyhumansai/openhuman: 60.0% of 120 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 54.1% of 318 commented ones traefik/traefik: 2.9% of 34 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 0.0% of 36 commented ones usebruno/bruno: 39.6% of 111 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 55.4% of 177 commented ones vercel/next.js: 11.9% of 388 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 20.2% of 504 commented ones vllm-project/vllm: 18.1% of 270 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 22.9% of 1451 commented ones warpdotdev/warp: 18.1% of 221 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 28.7% of 471 commented ones webpack/webpack: 28.9% of 38 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 49.1% of 55 commented ones withastro/astro: 6.7% of 75 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 39.8% of 83 commented ones zed-industries/zed: 13.7% of 358 silently approved PRs fixed later, against 14.0% of 343 commented ones Over 400 lines: median −6.9 pts median −6.9 pts
Repos in the six languages coderot reads with 30 or more PRs of each kind in the size band. Fixed later: a PR or push titled fix, bug, hotfix or revert changed its lines within 30 days. The gap is in percentage points. The bigger the PRs, the further left, and commented PRs are probably bigger even within a band.
Up to 20 lines there’s almost no gap: a median of −0.1 points. It grows with size, and even within a band commented PRs are probably the bigger ones. Silently approved PRs were fixed more often in 8 of the 161 repos. The two where they were fixed most often relative to commented ones, angular/angular and netdata/netdata, are ones where they’re as big as the commented ones, or bigger.
There’s no sign here that silent approval leads to more fixes. That’s not the same as silent approval being safe.